Basic Income Guarantee — Charity vs. Rights

On May 8, 2025, Dr. Heidi Janz of the University of Alberta made an online presentation contrasting two rationales for supporting the lives of people with disabilities:

The Charity Model operates on the centuries-old tenet of “noblesse oblige” — the idea that wealthy people should voluntarily do the right thing and give a portion of their wealth to the poor. That model distinguishes between the undeserving poor — whose bad life choices land them in trouble — and the deserving poor, who live with bodies or minds that prevent them from supporting themselves and participating in the economy. Unfortunately many social support and service agents seem to believe that pretty much everyone is undeserving, and that their job is to give out as little as possible to as few people as possible.

Dr. Janz helped her audience understand that the old “Charity Model” of disability support results in systems that are not only inadequate, but disrespectful of the basic humanity of people with disabilities.

She contrasted the Charity Model with the rights-based model, codified by the United Nations CRPD, Article 28.

UN CRPD Article 28 - the "easy-read" version.
The text in the box is from the “easy-read” version. The full text of Article 28 can be found here

Janz notes that the problem with the international rights-based model is the lack of substantive enforcement mechanisms on the domestic level. Changing from a charity-based model to a rights-based model requires a “paradigm shift” — i.e. a real turn-around in people’s ideas and attitudes — and that’s never easy. Enforcement requires formal rules and regulations. Canada is a signatory to the CRPD, and so is expected to make every effort to make positive changes in the lives of people with disabilities. To that end, in 2025, Canada introduced the Disability Benefit (CDB). It’s a start, but Disability Without Poverty (DWP) points out that the maximum benefit is $200/month — hardly enough to lift anyone out of poverty! — and not everyone can qualify to claim it. And in Dr. Janz’s home province, Alberta, CDB benefits can be clawed back from disabled people who might get to keep those benefits in other parts of Canada.

Screenshot from Heidi Janz’s presentation. (Illustration Credit: HJ/AI)

I find myself wondering what effective formal rules and regulations might be — rules that actually support the well-being of humans, whether or not they can work and contribute to the economy. They should be rules that don’t throw constant shade and shame on people whose disabilities keep them poor in the current capitalist economy.

In my view, one place to start is a well-being “floor” below which nobody can fall. Guaranteed Income plans, have been tried and proven to work effectively to the benefit of the whole local economy wherever the pilot program is run. The International Organization: Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN) states that “As the idea keeps moving from the margins to the centre of policy debates around the world, basic income is generating a vast and growing amount of data related to experiments and trials, public opinion polling and costings, and media and political debates.” People with disabilities would benefit from the basic amount that everyone gets, plus additional support based on what would be needed to thrive above the poverty line.

Paired with this, it is possible to imagine a well-being “ceiling”, above which a wealthy person will be not only taxed but compelled to invest in the well-being of others. There is huge resistance to this idea, but a wealth tax is gaining support. In the recent American midterm elections, California floated a wealth tax in a “ballot measure”. It was narrowly defeated, but the wealthy spent millions on lobbying against it. In the 20th Century, capitalist economics became addicted to the notion that “growth” is the purpose of the economy, regardless of into whose pockets the benefits of that growth flows. And clearly, the benefits land in the pockets of the wealthy more often than not. Under the 20th Century system, income inequality has ballooned. Right now, the world’s wealth is held and controlled by fewer than 1000 billionaires world-wide. (There are 80-odd billionaires in Canada!). One individual (EM) has been designated a trillionaire. That is an unimaginable amount of money.

Economist Kate Raworth argues that 20th-century economics, with its focus on endless growth, is old-fashioned and unfit for addressing 21st-century crises like extreme inequality and climate change. She introduces a visual model called the “Doughnut” to redefine the goal of economic activities. She believes that the economy exists to create a “safe and just space for humanity”. That space exists between a social foundation (or floor) of human rights and an ecological ceiling of planetary boundaries.

Image found on Page 38 of Raworth’s book.

The book is structured around seven key shifts in economic thinking designed to help achieve the refocussing and transformation of economic goals. While she does not focus on disability, she centres the “care economy” as a key measure of the necessary social foundation in a 21st century that is not only survivable, but that nourishes creativity and full participation of humans to the best of their ability.

So what does all of this have to do with MAID? Excellent question. Not all disabled Canadians who choose to die by MAID are poor, but lack of financial and other resources have been cited by many as the main reason behind their choice. For examples of this, visit our Remembering Lives Lived page and our Lives in the Balance page. Please visit respectfully.

In a realistic 21st Century economy, people have their basic needs met: housing, food, water, clothing, health care, education, income, social equity and inclusion, peace and justice. (We also refrain from overshooting the planet’s capacities to self-renew.) In order to arrive there, we have to find ways to prevent the concentration of wealth in a few hands (.1%) while 98% of the people struggle and 1.9% fall into homelessness and hopelessness. Perhaps a 21st Century economics like the Doughnut provides the “paradigm shift” that Dr. Janz was looking for. In a properly focussed economy, people with unmet needs can remind the stingy authorities that they are the MAIN REASON for an economy to exist in the first place: to create a “safe and just space for humanity” — not to enrich the few at the expense of the many.

The super-rich are intending to leave the spoiled, soiled Earth and the masses of poor people behind as they rocket off to colonize the Moon, Mars and planets beyond. I think disabled people along with the rest of us need to say, “Not on our dime, Elon!” What do you think?

Your thoughts matter! Share them here.